Media Analysis: Big AI is trying to own the pathway to work. Universities shouldn’t play along.

Updated: Sep 22
Original Article : Big AI is trying to own the pathway to work. Universities shouldn’t play along
Publisher: The Guardian III Author: Ella Hafermalz III Publication Date: 17th September 2026
Summary of the original article:
In her Guardian article, Ella Hafermalz argues that AI companies such as OpenAI are increasingly positioning themselves across the pathway from education to employment — and that universities should be wary of allowing this pathway to become dominated by commercial technology companies.
Her argument centres on a series of developments at OpenAI. The company has established its Student Collective, which is providing students with training, resources, funding and access to an OpenAI community. It is also developing AI education and certification programmes, while working with employers on AI skills and developing an OpenAI Jobs Platform.
Hafermalz argues that these initiatives are significant when considered together. Rather than simply providing an AI tool that students use during their studies, OpenAI could increasingly connect learning, skills, credentials and employment within a single ecosystem.
OpenAI itself describes its certification strategy as an attempt to connect “learning, certification and real economic opportunity”, while its AI Foundations programme allows learners to practise tasks, receive feedback and learn within ChatGPT.
Hafermalz sees this as potentially challenging the traditional role of universities. Her concern is that higher education could become increasingly shaped by the immediate requirements of technology companies and employers, rather than providing students with an independent educational pathway.
Why it matters for A4-AI (Academics for AI):
The significance of Hafermalz's argument goes beyond whether universities should use ChatGPT or other AI tools. The argument is one of boundaries.
If an AI company can provide students with the technology they use to learn, the training through which they develop AI skills, the credentials that demonstrate these skills and potentially a route to employers, then its role extends considerably beyond that of a technology provider. It is now a company embedded in the entire pathway to work for university students.
Hafermalz's article highlights this challenge and implications for academics.
Nevertheless, it is a reality that universities are making decisions to work closely with AI companies. As we have been reporting over the past few months, one university after another has been announcing partnerships with AI tech providers – despite concerns of some academics. This trend is likely to continue.
Why so? Because there are obvious reasons for universities to work with AI companies. Technology is changing rapidly, employers increasingly want AI capabilities, and universities can benefit from access to technology, expertise and training that would otherwise be difficult to develop internally.
But, let us not lose sight that Universities have a broader educational mission than technology adoption and amplification. Universities are also the educators of critical thinking, independent judgement and ethics – virtues that are as important as ever.
Questions for Academia:
How much of the pathway from university to employment should universities share with commercial AI companies?
What should a university degree provide that an AI company's training or certification cannot?
Who should define what “AI readiness” means for the next generation of graduates — universities, employers, technology companies, or some combination of all three?





Comments